Showing posts with label valuation. Show all posts
Showing posts with label valuation. Show all posts

Thursday, September 30, 2010

Is Facebook Worth $33 Billion Dollars? Who is Smoking Dope?

There was an article from the NY Times by Andrew Ross Sorkin about the Value of Facebook


There was also two competing blog posts one from GigaOm and one from Hacker News. Links are in the article. Without going into a drawn out discussion, and forget the two Blog Posts written by people with no financial experience, I will make this easy. Yesterday's post discussed the potential for misleading numbers from Facebook. I also had posted recently why Social is not in the C-Suite showing the ridiculously pitiful Facebook Fan Page performance for Big Brands.

I can use a myriad of stocks for comparison but since I used Apple yesterday let me use them.

If you had money to invest who would you invest in if you had to choose one:

Apple: 

Market Cap: 262Bil      - total value of all shares outstanding
P/E:  21.63                  - Price per $1 in earnings
EPS: 13.29                  - Earnings per Outstanding Share

Apples cost per dollar of revenue is $4.36 This company had $42bil in revenue for it's last fiscal year ending Sept 2009. It is on a $60bil revenue run rate as of last quarter ending Jun 26.


In fact they are on pace for $11bil in NET PROFITS. That is Microsoft and WalMart Territory!

Facebook:

Market Cap: $33bil
$1.5 bil in revenue
Profits? Unknown.

At $33bil you pay $22 per $1 in revenue
P/E ratio is unknown. Lets be generous and say that 33% is NET profit so $500mil

That would make the P/E ratio of 66 which would make it one of the Riskiest Investments in the Stock Market (Higher the P/E the higher the risk)

Who do you invest in?

Wednesday, September 29, 2010

Should We Believe the Facebook or DoubleClick Numbers.....

I have a Finance Degree. I analyze stocks all the time because I enjoy it. I can look at the fortune 500 stats for hours and find glee. One purpose Sky Pulse Media serves is to help Clients value the various Advertising and Marketing platforms and channels properly to maximize ROI. Everything has a value.

We also know the last Private Investor in Facebook gave a $23bil value. If Facebook goes public at less than that the investors lose money on paper and in reality. For example if I bought a 10% share in Facebook for $2.3 bil expecting the value of the stock to reach $40bil at IPO and instead it goes public at $11.5bil I lost half my investment.

Some numbers recently have me very perplexed:

A recent Ad Week article cited Facebook having 146mil unique visitors in July, while DoubleClick claims 540mil. Which one is correct? This is HUGE. Because 70% of Facebook users per their Stats Page are not in the US. So either there are 43mil monthly US users or 162mil. Which is it?

Secondly DopubleClick Claims 690Bil Page views in July for Facebook.  Is this possible even if 540mil users are accurate? That comes out to 42 page views per user each day assuming all 540mil log in each day. Since Facebook claims only 200mil+ that means everyone who logs in each day averages over 100 page views per day. That seems absolutely impossible.

Also Facebook claims 55mins per day per user, Nielsen claims 6hrs per user per month!

This means something is either being measured differently for Facebook because of the way the website is structured. Or the measurements are completely untrue. The big issue is Wall Street will see the exact same thing and completely discount the value of Facebook because they won't know what to believe.

One last measure. If you buy Apple stock the cost is $6 per $1 of Apple Revenue. At the same valuation Facebook is worth $9bil. Would you pay $15 per $1 of revenue for Facebook instead of buying Apple. Apple makes Computers, MP3 Players, Tablets, Phones and has revenue streams with ITunes and the APP store. Facebook could go the way of Myspace in 3 years. Do you feel Facebook has the dedicated loyalty Apple has?

Something to think about. My next post will discuss why Traffic Numbers might be (or can be) fudged.